Speculation is Defi's double-edged sword

Opinion: Billy Campana, Contract Developer, API3

Speculation is the basis for the price discovery of traditional financial institutions such as hedge funds and major banks, and plays an important role in daily business. It is a mechanism that allows you to establish a reliable assessment of everything from simple inventory and bonds to complex derivatives and structured products.

Decentralized finance (DEFI) is often criticized for its speculative “casino” nature, but this is actually one of its strengths. It makes practices like arbitrage accessible to anyone and allows them to participate in opportunities that are out of reach.

Defi Volatility

Critics highlight Defi's extreme volatility. This was a concern exemplified by the recent 15% price drop in Ether (ETH), which led to the liquidation of a long position of over $100 million. These dramatic market movements continuously test the market's resilience to ecosystems and investor confidence.

The Defi platform is an accusation that gambling venues are essentially functioning when they last throughout the industry. Such criticisms have gained further traction and revealed systematic vulnerabilities that allow speculative activity to be introduced into a wider ecosystem following the collision of several well-known memocoin, with market values ​​exceeding $46 billion.

Additionally, BYBit Hack has recently highlighted key security concerns, uncovering critical vulnerabilities within the Defi infrastructure, causing intense scrutiny of sector security protocols. These systematic risks only escalate institutional skepticism, resulting in an increasingly voiced increase in transparency and comprehensive regulatory oversight.

At the same time, the media narrative surrounding defi overwhelmingly focuses on its grand failure, the rise in institutional skepticism and sustained market instability. This one-sided portrayal continues to challenge Defi's reliability as a serious financial ecosystem capable of responsible innovation.

Evening stadium

Critics have consistently overlooked democratizing the same speculative mechanisms traditional finance always employs for price discovery. The fundamental difference is that from the Wall Street gatekeeper, they no longer control those who benefit from these opportunities.

Traditional finances have historically limited arbitrage opportunities for institutional players with privileged access, but they effectively remove these gatekeepers, allowing anyone with an internet connection to participate in the price discovery process that hedge funds and banks have monopolized for decades.

Smart contracts once revolutionised financial operations that required a team of privileged access and highly paid professionals. Smart contracts effectively break down artificial barriers that have systematically protected ordinary people from sophisticated markets.

Recent: BitWise makes the first institutional definition assignment

Major financial institutions are increasingly aware of this paradigm shift, with established companies gradually adopting defi mechanisms to automate transactions and increase operational efficiency. Institutional adoption does not dismiss it as merely a gamble, but examines the inference as a legitimate financial practice.

Arbitrage Utopia

This unprecedented democratization emerges specifically in decentralized lending platforms that enable automated market makers (AMMs), providing liquidity exclusively for institutional market makers with a large number of capital reserves and earning previously reserved fees.

Unprecedented data transparency across blockchain networks allows even non-qualified cryptocurrencies to enable capital-efficient arbitration opportunities across multiple blockchain ecosystems without requiring participants to millions of prepaid collateral that traditional finance requires.

As institutional involvement continues to grow and regulatory frameworks gradually mature, these speculative mechanisms evolve steadily towards the same legitimacy and the same legitimacy that traditional financial instruments enjoy. This evolution makes it clear that speculation itself was never a problem. That was the exclusive access to that advantage.

Practical implementations of this democratized speculation include cross-crossing intersections via Defi aggregators and cross-chain bridges via cross-chain bridges. This includes automated liquidation mechanisms that naturally equalize asset prices across various blockchains and maintain the solvent in the system.

All these components serve the same basic purpose as traditional financial products, but have fundamentally expanded access to participants around the world.

As institutional investors and traditional financial markets have increased engagement from US regulatory agencies and politicians, Defi has to remember its core value proposition.

The real value of Defi is not to replicate the current structures in which powerful people can benefit from the ways that normal people don't have access to, but to make these opaque systems transparent and open to everyone.

Rather than apologizing for speculation, the industry needs to embrace it and refine it as an innovative tool. This brings billions of financial opportunities systematically removed from traditional markets.

Defi's innovation is more than just technology. It also creates a financial system where opportunities are social and are determined not by privilege but by insight, creativity and willingness to participate. The future belongs to people who can eliminate speculation, not to those who are fair, transparent and accessible to everyone.

Opinion: Billy Campana, Contract Developer, API3

This article is for general informational purposes and is not intended to be considered legal or investment advice, and should not be done. The views, thoughts and opinions expressed here are the authors alone and do not necessarily reflect or express Cointregraph's views and opinions.